 | Stewart Granger als Old Surehand |
 | Pierre Brice als Winnetou |
 | Elke Sommer als Annie Dillman |
 | Götz George als Martin Baumann Jr. |
 | Walter Barnes als Martin Baumann Sr. |
 | Renato Baldini als Judge Leader |
 | Terence Hill als Baker Jr. |
 | Sieghardt Rupp als Preston |
 | Milan Srdoč als Old Wabble |
 | Miha Baloh als 'Reverend' Weller |
 | Louis Velle als Gordon |
 | Gojko Mitić als Wokadeh |
 | Dunja Rajter als Betsy (uncredited) |
 | Voja Mirić als Stewart |
 | Ilija Ivezić als Jackie |
| Đorđe Nenadović als Miller |
| Nevenka Benković als Settler woman (uncredited) |
| Šime Jagarinac als Schoschone (uncredited) |
| Alfred Vohrer | Director |
| Erwin Gitt | Producer |
| Eberhard Keindorff | Screenplay |
| Karl May | Novel |
| Horst Wendlandt | Producer |
| Hermann Haller | Editor |
| Stipe Gurdulic | Producer |
| Martin Böttcher | Music |
| Karl Löb | Director of Photography |
| Irms Pauli | Costume Design |
| Vladimir Tadej | Production Design |
| Johanna Sibelius | Screenplay |
| Irms Pauli | Costume Designer |
| Erich L. Schmekel | Makeup Artist |
| Irmgard Forster | Makeup Artist |
| Leif Feilberg | Assistant Production Coordinator |
| Eberhard Junkersdorf | Production Manager |
| Wolfgang Kühnlenz | Production Manager |
| Herbert Kerz | Production Manager |
| Vojdrac Bericcz | Second Unit First Assistant Director |
| Stipe Delić | Second Unit Director |
| Eva Ebner | Assistant Director |
| Otto Fechtner | Property Master |
| Matija Barbalić | Sound |
| Max Galinsky | Sound Mixer |
| Hans-Walter Kramski | Foley Artist |
| Erwin Lange | Pyrotechnician |
| Joachim Gitt | Assistant Camera |
| Kreso Grcevic | Camera Operator |
| Karl Reiter | Still Photographer |
| Gerd-Victor Krau | Still Photographer |
| Rudolf Sandtner | Camera Operator |
| Lothar Winkler | Still Photographer |
| Helmut Preuss | Dresser |
| Gisela Neumann | Assistant Editor |
| Katharina Scheu | Script Supervisor |
| Editha Busch | Production Secretary |
| Kilian Rebentrost | Finance |
