 | Devin France als Wendy |
 | Shay Walker als Angela Darling |
 | Tommie Lynn Milazzo als Wendy (Baby) |
 | Gage Naquin als Douglas |
 | Yashua Mack als Peter Pan |
| Gavin Naquin als James |
| Ahmad Cage als Sweet Heavy |
| Krzysztof Meyn als Thomas |
| Romyri Ross als Cudjoe Head |
| Stephanie Lynn Wilson als Adult Wendy (voice) |
 | Lowell Landes als Buzzo |
| Matt Owens als Tee Goose |
| Kevin Pugh als James Hook |
| Cleopatra King Welch als Jane |
| Irwin Lewis als Sweet Heavy (Adult) |
| Benh Zeitlin | Director |
| Benh Zeitlin | Writer |
| Eliza Zeitlin | Writer |
| Mary Kerrigan | Associate Producer |
| Paul S. Mezey | Producer |
| Dan Janvey | Producer |
| Joseph Latson | Associate Producer |
| Nathan Harrison | Co-Producer |
| Becky Glupczynski | Producer |
| Josh Penn | Producer |
| Sturla Brandth Grøvlen | Director of Photography |
| Scott Cummings | Editor |
| Michael Gottwald | Executive Producer |
| Jeremy Newmark | Co-Producer |
| Affonso Gonçalves | Editor |
| Benh Zeitlin | Original Music Composer |
| Dan Romer | Original Music Composer |
| Lisa Mustafa | Makeup Department Head |
| Martin Czembor | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Jesy Rae Buhl | Casting |
| Stacy Jansen | Costume Design |
| Michael Russo | Sound Mixer |
| Ruy García | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Eliza Zeitlin | Production Design |
| Andres Moreno | Sound Mixer |
| Michael McMenomy | Sound Effects Editor |
| Chris Foster | Sound Effects Editor |
| Allison Jackson | Sound Mixer |
| Lance Mitchell | Art Direction |
| Anouck Sullivan | Makeup Artist |
| Mark Bendeck | Boom Operator |
| Andy Eklund | Art Direction |
| Adan Salas Cantu | Boom Operator |
| Garin W. Sparks | Set Medic |
| Kyle Zemborain | VFX Artist |
