 | Jason Ritter als Ben Dwellman |
 | Jake Sandvig als Alan Manilow |
 | Chandler Canterbury als Kelsey Patterson |
 | Rebecca Hall als Melanie 'Mel' Manilow |
 | Todd Louiso als Marty |
 | Gabriel Macht als Wyatt |
 | Sally Kirkland als Older Jewish Lady |
 | Elmarie Wendel als The Mark |
 | Carrie Preston als Lynette |
 | Johnny Simmons als Kelsey Patterson (Age 18) |
 | Amanda Seyfried als Amanda (uncredited) |
| Brian Crano | Director |
| Jake Sandvig | Writer |
| Brian Crano | Writer |
| Johnny Flynn | Music |
| Jennifer Barrons | Producer |
| Brian Crano | Producer |
| Lucy Barzun Donnelly | Producer |
| Craig Eisenberg | Co-Producer |
| Peter Friedlander | Producer |
| Max Hurwitz | Associate Producer |
| Jake Sandvig | Co-Producer |
| Brian A. Kates | Editor |
| Travis Sittard | Editor |
| Brad Gilmore | Casting |
| Bradley Thordarson | Production Design |
| Justin Allen | Art Direction |
| Rachelle House | Art Direction |
| Jeanne Nicholas | Set Decoration |
| Elisabeth Stewart | Set Decoration |
| Michelle Sandvig | Costume Design |
| Keri Ann Luevano | Makeup & Hair |
| Quyen Tran | Director of Photography |
| Byron Shah | Director of Photography |
