 | Ira Glass als Host |
 | Mike Birbiglia als Himself |
 | Sasheer Zamata als Herself |
 | Lin-Manuel Miranda als Narrator |
 | Lindsay Mendez als Naomi |
| Stephin Merritt als Himself (Musical Guest) |
 | James Ransone als David |
 | Anthony Ramos als Justin Laboy |
 | Josh Hamilton als Joshua |
 | Joshuah Bearman als Narrator |
| Seth Lind | Director |
| Joshuah Bearman | Writer |
| Mike Birbiglia | Writer |
| Ira Glass | Writer |
| Sasheer Zamata | Writer |
| Ben Cohen | Producer |
| Ben Katz | Producer |
| Allison Davis | Producer |
| Robert Saenz De Viteri | Producer |
| Ira Glass | Executive Producer |
| Robyn Semien | Producer |
| Reuben Kleiner | Cinematography |
| Ben Cohen | Editor |
| Seth Lind | Editor |
| Lin-Manuel Miranda | Writer |
